How to Choose ETFs: Common Mistakes to Avoid

When you first start looking at ETF options, you're hit with hundreds of names. You've got things tracking indices, things that pay dividends, leveraged products, and commodity ETFs all mixed together on one screen, which can make it super confusing about where to even start.
In this post, we're going to break down ETFs by type to see which ones fit different investors, and we'll cover essential things you need to check before you buy, like trading hours and what's in the fund. Our goal isn't to know everything; it's to help you pick the one product that matches your specific goals.
A Quick Guide to the Main Types of ETFs
Think of an ETF as a fund that you can buy and sell on an exchange, just like a stock. Even though they're all ETFs, what they hold inside changes their entire nature. If you categorize them first, the list of options won't seem so overwhelming.
- Index Tracking: These are designed to mirror the movements of a specific market index. Because their structure is straightforward, they are often used by investors planning to hold them for the long haul.
- Bond Funds: These hold government or corporate bonds, so their value moves based on interest rate changes. These are good for people who want to reduce their stock exposure.
- Dividend/Covered Call Funds: These generate income through dividends or by selling options, which they distribute to you. While the distribution rate might look high, it can limit the potential for the stock price to rise.
- Leveraged/Inverse Funds: These are designed to either multiply the daily return of an index or move in the opposite direction. These are generally best suited for short-term trading.
- Commodity Funds: These track the prices of physical goods like gold, crude oil, or agricultural products. Since they often move independently of stocks, they can be considered for diversification.
By making these distinctions first, you can cut down on the mistakes of judging a product based only on its name.
When Choosing a Leveraged ETF, Keep Your Time Horizon Short
Leveraged ETFs aim to achieve a multiple of the underlying index's daily return. When the index goes up, your gains are magnified by that multiple, but when it drops, your losses are also magnified. This is where the most common misunderstanding comes in.
A lot of people think, "If the index goes up over a year, the leveraged product will double," but because leveraged ETFs compound daily returns, their cumulative performance can drift significantly from the index's total return over longer periods. If the market stays flat or swings wildly, holding them long-term might not yield the results you expect.
Therefore, it's safer to treat leveraged ETFs as a short-term strategy aimed at specific events or brief trends, rather than a component of long-term asset allocation that you build up with your monthly savings.
Know Exactly What Commodities ETFs Track
Just because it's called a commodity ETF doesn't mean it physically holds barrels of oil or bars of gold. Many of these products track prices using futures contracts, and this process can lead to costs from contract rollovers or price discrepancies.
Even if two ETFs have similar names, their underlying assets and how they operate can be completely different, so you absolutely must read the prospectus to understand the base assets and the management style. Commodities often move differently than stocks, sometimes reacting to inflation or the strength of the dollar, so they are often considered for a small part of a portfolio.
However, because they can be very volatile, most financial advisors recommend keeping the percentage of your total assets allocated to them small.
Understanding ETF Trading Hours and Execution Types
Since ETFs trade on exchanges just like domestic stocks, they operate within set trading hours. ETFs listed in the U.S. trade according to the U.S. exchange hours, while those listed in Korea trade during Korean market hours.
If you want to buy a U.S. ETF, you might find yourself trading during the night or early morning in Korea. When placing an order, be sure to check the difference between a market order and a limit order. For ETFs with low trading volume, the bid-ask spread can be wide, meaning a market order might execute at a price you don't expect.
It's also wise to avoid trading during volatile times, such as right after the market opens or just before it closes.
How to Check the Holdings of an ETF
Even if an ETF's name includes a specific index, the actual stocks it holds and their weight can vary depending on the fund manager and the time you look. Before you buy, it’s really important to check the list of top holdings and their respective weights to make sure they don't overlap with stocks you already own.
- Check the fund manager's materials to confirm the underlying index and how it tracks that index.
- Look at the top holdings and their weightings.
- Review whether there are any overlaps with individual stocks you own or other ETFs.
- Compare the total expense ratio and trading volume.
Even if two products track the same index, your actual return can differ based on the expense ratio and trading volume, so make sure to compare those two things.
Common Mistakes to Avoid When Choosing an ETF
First off, only looking at the distribution rate (dividend yield) is a big mistake. An ETF with a high distribution rate might actually be structured in a way that reduces your principal. Second, buying leveraged products through long-term dollar-cost averaging. Third, quickly buying thinly traded stocks using a market order. Fourth, misunderstanding what the ETF tracks just by reading its name. You can prevent most of these pitfalls just by making it a habit to read the fund's prospectus.
Frequently Asked Questions About ETFs
What are the trading hours for ETFs?
ETFs listed in the US trade during regular US market hours. ETFs listed overseas trade according to the hours of their respective exchanges, so there will be a time difference from US time. Before placing an order, check the trading hours for the specific product on your brokerage app.
Where can I find the holdings of an ETF?
You can find the constituent stocks and their weights on the fund manager's website or in the product information documents. Since the composition changes periodically, it's best to look at the most up-to-date information right before you buy.
Are ETFs guaranteed to protect my principal?
No, ETFs are products whose price moves with the market, just like stocks, so your principal is not guaranteed. Especially with leveraged or commodity ETFs, the potential for losses can be significant, so only invest what you can afford to lose.
Following the basic principles taught by Smart Investor, start by checking the investment objective, structure, and trading terms before focusing on the product name. The most practical first step is to review your current portfolio to see if any ETFs overlap with what you already hold.
